Darwin's Black Box

Darwin's Black Box

The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution

Book - 2006
Average Rating:
10
Rate this:
Publisher: New York : Free Press, 2006.
Edition: 10th anniversary ed.
ISBN: 9780684827544
0684827549
9780743290319
0743290313
Branch Call Number: 576. 82 BEH 2006
Characteristics: xii, 329 p. : ill.

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

r
rswcove
Mar 29, 2016

The funny thing about this book and its attempted deconstruction of Darwin's theory of natural selection is that it is dated. Or more correctly, it was outdated before it was published. Behe served as an expert witness in a trial to determine if Intelligent design were science or religion (the Bush appointed Conservative judge found that ID was religion by the way, and therefore could not be presented in Science Classrooms as science). On the witness stand, Behe's arguments (also presented in this book) fell apart as long ago discredited and out of date and simply wrong. Behe admitted to not reading papers that would contradict his preferred viewpoint and further admitted that his view of science was so broad that it would also have to include astrology.

Behe is a biologist and one of the few actual experts that Intelligent Design can marshal to its defense, but this book was outdated when Behe wrote it, and is a joke now.

n
naturalist
Dec 11, 2012

“Intelligent Design” (ID) is to evolutionary biology as alchemy is to chemistry, as astrology is to astronomy
and,
"Gravity (a theory in crisis) vs. Intelligent Falling."
For the crushing defeat of the creationists' wedge strategy, watch Judgment Day : Intelligent Design on Trial 2008
Tammy Kitzmiller, et al. v. Dover Area School District, et al. (400 F. Supp. 2d 707, Docket no. 4cv2688)
and,
Quoting Wikipedia: Michael J. Behe (b.1952) is an intelligent design advocate. He currently serves as professor of biochemistry at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania and as a senior fellow of the Discovery Institute's Center for Science and Culture. Behe is best known for his argument for irreducible complexity, which asserts that some biochemical structures are too complex to be adequately explained by known evolutionary mechanisms and are therefore more probably the result of intelligent design. Behe has testified in several court cases related to intelligent design, including the court case Kitzmiller v. Dover Area School District that resulted in a ruling that intelligent design was religious in nature. Behe's claims about the irreducible complexity of essential cellular structures have been rejected by the vast majority of the scientific community, and his own biology department at Lehigh University published an official statement opposing Behe's views and intelligent design.
continued,
“Michael Behe, arguing that intelligent design should be allowable in public schools, admitted that his definition of science was broad enough to include astrology.” http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Young_Earth_creationism

i
ivance
Sep 22, 2012

As I studied bilogy in college, I developed an uncomfortable feeling about the theory of evolution. The inter-cellular structures and components were very complex. As our resolution increases with technology, we are able to see how much more complex the inner workings of the cell are. The second law of thermodynamics and entropy bothered me when trying to get my head around complex systems arising out of chance. This book is very thought provoking.

h
Hello_Seattle
Aug 15, 2012

So here's the deal. This is a great book, filled with lots of the holes that Darwinism leaves. So therefore with this in mind, this book shouldn't be read by ignorant atheists, who don't believe anything a creationist has to say, and then goes and trumpets about very little and obscure "evidence" in anyway they can, and they seem to think that some atheistic movies can prove some points, and they bring up these points even when they have nothing to do with the entire field of science involved in the discussion. Biologically even a amoeba can't change, it is an exact copy of the parent because it reproduces asexually.

Darwinism is the biggest joke ever released onto the scientific community.

c
capshh
Aug 01, 2012

A very good book for the questioning mind. If you are open to look at the facts, Michael Behe provides them in abundance. He takes no position of the evolution theory, just provides evidence that is not refutable.

j
jbolta
Jan 20, 2012

Brilliant, clear thinking and focused arguments

c
cstadt
Jul 30, 2011

One strength of this book is it shows that the debate in origins science is not between religious belief (creation-ism) on the one hand, and scientific knowledge (evolution) on the other, but that a rigorous debate can take place squarely in the realm of scientific evidence. Keep your eyes open for those who dismiss this book and its arguments by simply waving their hands and saying "Oh, its all been refuted." That close-mindedness smacks of going beyond the evidence and into the realm of evolution-ism, which quite frankly is a religious commitment based on the pronouncements of the secular priesthood which would shut down all discussion which is critical of Darwin.

d
dedwards
Jul 24, 2011

Same old, same old. Behe uses the standard "irreducible complexity" of the creationists that has been shot down so many times is species and structure - now he applies it to biochemistry. A rather tired argument. I was hoping to see if the "creation" science actually had some experiments. Alas, this is just a usual attack on evolution.

i
IncendiaAngelus
Jul 23, 2011

An interesting read. I didn't agree with all of his perspectives, but he's got some good points worth consideration.

a
AdawgLang
Jun 27, 2011

See 'Evolution: The Triumph of an Idea' by Carl Zimmer for evidence against many of the claims made by Behe.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

There are no age suitabilities for this title yet.

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at CPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top